top of page

SEO Audit: A Practical Website Health Check for Businesses

Jun 5, 2024
13 min read

Updated: 16 hours ago

SEO Audit: How to Analyse Your Website and Build an Action Plan | IBIFOUNDRY

IBIFOUNDRY · Dr Simon Edition

Primary keyword: SEO audit · Supporting keyword: website audit

SEO Audit: How to Analyse Your Website and Build an Action Plan

Meta description:Learn how to conduct an SEO audit using the OOK framework: On-Website analysis, Off-Website competitor research and Keyword analysis.

Have you ever looked at your website and wondered why it is not attracting the right visitors from Google? Have you published useful articles but still struggle to understand which technical or content problems are holding them back? And if someone handed you an SEO report today, would you know which recommendations to implement first?

Those are the questions I want this guide to help you answer. An SEO audit should not leave you with a frightening list of errors or a colourful dashboard that tells you very little about what to do next.

Hello, I am Simon Taki Zaku, founder of IBIFOUNDRY LIMITED. In this guide, I will walk you through the approach I use to think about website audits, including my OOK SEO Audit Strategy: On-Website analysis, Off-Website competitor analysis and Keyword analysis.

Read this first:An audit does not guarantee rankings, traffic growth or a specific result by a particular date. It identifies evidence-based problems and opportunities. Results depend on implementation, competition, the website, the market and how search systems crawl, index and rank content.

What you will get from this guide:a practical audit sequence, the tools and data worth checking, a report structure, a prioritisation method and a checklist you can use on your own website.

On this page


What an SEO Audit Actually Means

An SEO audit is a structured examination of a website's technical accessibility, indexability, content, search performance, internal links, user experience and external link profile. Its purpose is to identify what is preventing important pages from being discovered, understood, trusted or chosen in search results.

A useful audit does more than identify errors. It explains the evidence, why each issue matters, which pages are affected, what should change and how the result will be checked after implementation.

A content audit is one part of the wider process. It examines whether pages satisfy search intent, provide original value, remain accurate, cover the subject adequately and deserve to be maintained, improved, consolidated or retired.

Why a Website Needs an SEO Audit

A website can look attractive and still have pages that search engines cannot access properly. It can publish regularly while targeting overlapping keywords, leaving important pages orphaned, or attracting visitors who are unlikely to become customers.

An audit helps connect technical findings to business priorities. For a Nigerian business, for example, the right questions may include whether service pages target the locations actually served, whether mobile visitors can use enquiry forms, whether prices and contact details are current, and whether the pages appearing in Google are the pages that generate enquiries.

The goal is not to chase a perfect score from an SEO tool. The goal is to remove meaningful obstacles and identify the next improvements that are most likely to help the business.

The OOK SEO Audit Strategy

I organise the process around three connected areas. The framework is simple to remember, but each stage needs careful evidence gathering.

Stage

Meaning

Core question

O — On-Website

Review the website itself: technical health, pages, content, internal links and performance.

What is happening on our own website?

O — Off-Website

Study relevant competitors, their visible search performance, content coverage and referring links.

What can the search results and competing pages teach us?

K — Keyword Analysis

Use first-party data, competitor observations and audience needs to build a focused keyword map.

Which searches should each page satisfy?

The stages inform one another. Your own website data shows where performance is weak; competitor research helps reveal the level and format of content competing in the search results; keyword analysis turns those findings into a page-level plan.

O: On-Website Analysis

This is where I begin: the website must be able to serve visitors and make its important pages accessible to search engines. I review the site in layers rather than treating one automated score as the audit.

Technical accessibility and indexability

First, establish whether the important URLs can be crawled and indexed. A page can be technically present on a website but unavailable to search because of blocking directives, an incorrect canonical, a noindex instruction, a server error or a rendering problem.

  • Robots.txt:check that it does not unintentionally block important sections. Robots.txt controls crawling; it is not a reliable way to remove a URL from Google's index.

  • XML sitemap:confirm that it contains the canonical URLs you want search engines to discover and that it is accessible and current.

  • Status codes:identify broken pages, server errors, redirect loops and unnecessary redirect chains.

  • Canonical tags:check that similar URL variants identify the preferred page consistently.

  • Internal links:make sure important pages can be reached through useful links rather than existing as isolated URLs.

  • Rendering:where a site relies heavily on JavaScript, check that important content and links are available to search engines after rendering.

Use Google Search Console's URL Inspection tool to investigate representative URLs. Compare the live test with Google's indexed information; do not assume that submitting a URL guarantees indexing.

Mobile experience and page performance

Review the actual mobile experience. Text should be readable, navigation usable, buttons easy to tap, images appropriately sized and forms practical to complete on a phone.

Use PageSpeed Insights to inspect performance. It reports lab diagnostics and, where available, field data from the Chrome User Experience Report. Pay attention to the Core Web Vitals: Largest Contentful Paint (LCP), Interaction to Next Paint (INP) and Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS).

Metric

Good threshold

What it tells you

LCP

2.5 seconds or less

How quickly the main content appears.

INP

200 milliseconds or less

How responsive the page is to user interactions.

CLS

0.1 or less

How stable the layout is while loading.

These thresholds are assessed at the 75th percentile. A passing score does not guarantee rankings, and a poor score should be investigated in context rather than treated as the only explanation for weak search performance.

AMP is not a mandatory SEO requirement. Focus on a fast, accessible, mobile-friendly experience and fix the causes of poor performance on the pages that matter.

Page-level SEO elements

Review the important pages individually. Check whether each page has a descriptive title, a useful meta description, one clear main heading, logical subheadings, descriptive image alt text where images convey information, and a URL that accurately represents the page.

Do not force the same keyword into every heading. The wording should help the reader understand the page and should reflect its actual subject.

Content quality and search intent

Compare each important page with the query it is supposed to answer. Does it answer the question directly? Is the information accurate and current? Does it offer something useful beyond a rearrangement of generic information?

Look for thin pages, outdated information, missing explanations, unsupported claims, pages that repeat one another and content that attracts the wrong audience. Similar content does not automatically mean a Google penalty; the practical concern is whether the pages create unnecessary duplication, confusing canonical signals or competing answers for the same intent.

When two pages target substantially the same intent, decide whether one should be improved, whether unique material should be consolidated, or whether they genuinely serve different readers. Do not create another URL just because a related phrase exists.

Internal linking and site structure

Internal links help people and search engines understand how pages relate. Identify important pages with too few internal links, links pointing to redirects or errors, vague anchor text and navigation paths that make key information difficult to find.

Use descriptive anchor text and link related pages where the connection genuinely helps the reader. Avoid adding links simply to meet a numerical target.

Analytics and search performance

Use Google Search Console to understand how the site appears in Google Search: queries, pages, clicks, impressions, click-through rate, average position, countries and devices. Compare time periods carefully and inspect page-level and query-level patterns.

Use Google Analytics 4 to understand what visitors do after arriving: engagement, key events and conversions, provided the tracking is configured correctly. Search Console and GA4 answer different questions; neither should be treated as a substitute for the other.

Backlink profile

Review referring domains and links for relevance, editorial context, quality, patterns and potential risk. A large number of backlinks is not automatically a sign of strength.

Third-party metrics such as Moz Domain Authority are proprietary comparative indicators. They are not Google metrics and should not be presented as direct Google ranking factors. Do not buy links or pursue manipulative schemes, and do not disavow links casually without a clear reason and careful review.

O: Off-Website and Competitor Analysis

The second O in my framework looks beyond your own website. I examine the pages that compete for the same searches and the websites that repeatedly appear in the results.

Start with the actual search results for your priority topics and locations. Record which URLs rank, what type of page they are, the questions they answer, how they organise information, and whether the results show local packs, videos, product listings or other search features.

Then compare relevant competitors across a few dimensions:

  • Top-ranking pages:identify the pages that attract visibility for the searches that matter to your business.

  • Content coverage:compare the questions, subtopics, examples and formats they address.

  • Search intent:check whether Google is rewarding service pages, guides, category pages, local listings or another format.

  • Referring links:inspect relevant websites linking to competing pages and understand the editorial reason for those links.

  • Publishing patterns:note whether competitors maintain evergreen guides, publish news, update service pages or build location-specific resources.

Tools can help discover competitor keywords and backlinks, but treat estimates as estimates. Confirm important opportunities against the live search results and your own Search Console data.

My rule:competitor analysis is not copying. I want to understand why a competing page is useful, identify what the reader still needs, and build a stronger answer that fits the business I am auditing.

K: Keyword Analysis

The final stage turns the audit findings into a focused content and page plan. I do not want several IbiFoundry pages chasing the same search intent. Each page needs a clearly assigned keyword owner.

For this article, the ownership is:

  • Primary keyword:SEO audit.

  • Supporting keyword:website audit.

Long-tail queries and close variants should be answered naturally within the article when they belong to the same intent. They do not automatically justify separate pages.

Build a page-level keyword map

For every important URL, record one primary keyword and, where genuinely useful, one closely related supporting keyword. Then map related questions and variants to the page that best satisfies them.

Before assigning a keyword, review the search results, location, language, device context, business value and the content format people appear to want. Search volume alone does not establish that a keyword is a good opportunity.

Use Search Console queries to discover what a page already receives impressions for. Use keyword research tools to expand the list, then manually check whether the phrases share the same intent.

Prevent keyword cannibalisation

Keyword cannibalisation is often used too loosely. Two pages appearing for the same query is not automatically a problem. The stronger warning sign is when multiple pages are deliberately built for the same intent and repeatedly compete to be the best answer.

When overlap exists, compare each URL's search performance, backlinks, internal links, content quality, publication history and conversion role. Select the page that should own the intent, consolidate unique value into it, update internal links and redirect the retired URL when appropriate.

That is the exact approach being applied to this SEO-audit resource: one authoritative page, not two competing articles.

How to Prepare an SEO Audit Report

A report should help a business owner make decisions. It should not overwhelm them with raw exports or unexplained tool warnings.

For every finding, include the following information:

Report field

What to include

Issue

A concise description of what is wrong or what opportunity exists.

Evidence

The affected URL, screenshot, crawl result, Search Console data or other supporting observation.

Impact

Why it matters to crawling, indexing, relevance, user experience or business outcomes.

Recommendation

The specific action that should be taken.

Priority

Blocker, high, medium or low, with a reason.

Owner and effort

Who should implement it and the estimated level of work.

Validation

How the team will confirm the fix worked.

Separate confirmed problems from hypotheses and opportunities. If data is missing, state that limitation rather than filling the gap with an assumption.

How to Prioritise Audit Findings

Not every warning deserves immediate attention. I recommend evaluating impact, confidence and effort together.

  • Blockers:issues that prevent important pages from being accessed, crawled or indexed, such as accidental noindex directives or widespread server errors.

  • High priority:problems affecting important commercial pages, major intent mismatches, broken conversion journeys or significant internal-linking weaknesses.

  • Medium priority:meaningful improvements to content depth, metadata, page structure, image delivery or internal links.

  • Opportunities:new content gaps, useful supporting resources, relevant digital PR opportunities and refinements that can be tested over time.

Agree on an implementation order with the people responsible for the website. After changes are made, validate the technical fix and monitor the relevant pages and queries over an appropriate period.

SEO Audit Tools Worth Using

You do not need every paid SEO platform to begin. Choose tools based on the question you need to answer.

Tool

Useful for

Search performance, indexing reports, sitemap status and URL inspection.

Page performance diagnostics and Core Web Vitals field data where available.

Visitor behaviour, engagement and configured conversion events.

Official guidance on crawling, indexing, structured data and search essentials.

Checking the syntax and structure of Schema.org markup.

Checking eligibility for supported Google rich results.

Crawling URLs and examining page-level technical elements.

Competitive research, keyword discovery and backlink analysis, subject to plan limits and data coverage.

Always verify important findings. A tool's warning is a prompt to investigate, not automatic proof that Google is treating a page negatively.

SEO Audit Mistakes I Want You to Avoid


  • Chasing tool scores:a high score does not guarantee rankings, leads or sales.

  • Treating every warning as urgent:prioritise issues by evidence and likely impact.

  • Confusing third-party authority metrics with Google signals:use them only as comparative estimates.

  • Assuming AMP is compulsory:focus on a strong mobile experience and sound performance.

  • Creating a new page for every keyword variation:group queries by intent and assign one page to own each topic.

  • Removing pages without checking their value:inspect traffic, links, conversions and unique information before consolidating or redirecting.

  • Promising guaranteed rankings:no honest audit can guarantee a specific position or timetable.

  • Reporting problems without solutions:every meaningful finding needs a clear recommendation and validation method.


Practical Website SEO Audit Checklist

Use this checklist as a starting point. Adapt it to the website's size, platform, market and business goals.

  • Confirm the website's priority pages and business objectives.

  • Review Search Console clicks, impressions, queries, pages, countries and devices.

  • Check indexing and inspect representative URLs.

  • Review robots.txt, XML sitemap, status codes and redirects.

  • Check canonical tags, duplicate URL variants and indexation directives.

  • Review mobile usability and Core Web Vitals.

  • Inspect page titles, meta descriptions, headings and image alt text.

  • Evaluate content accuracy, intent match, originality and topical completeness.

  • Identify overlapping pages and assign one keyword owner per search intent.

  • Review internal links and important orphaned pages.

  • Assess referring domains and backlink relevance without relying on one authority score.

  • Compare relevant competitor pages and search result formats.

  • Build a keyword map for existing and genuinely missing pages.

  • Prepare an action plan with evidence, priority, owner and validation steps.

  • Measure implementation and outcomes after changes are made.


Frequently Asked Questions About SEO Audits


What is an SEO audit?

An SEO audit is a structured review of a website's technical health, content, internal links, search performance and external link profile. It identifies evidence-based issues and opportunities for improving organic search visibility and the visitor experience.

How do I perform an SEO audit on my website?

Start with your goals and Search Console data. Review technical accessibility, indexability, mobile performance, page-level SEO, content quality, internal links and backlinks; then study relevant competitors and build a keyword map.

What should an SEO audit report include?

It should include the issue, evidence, affected URLs, likely impact, recommended fix, priority, implementation owner and a way to validate the change. It should distinguish confirmed issues from assumptions.

Which free tools can I use for an SEO audit?

Google Search Console, PageSpeed Insights, Google Analytics 4, Google Search Central documentation, the Rich Results Test and Schema Markup Validator are useful starting points. Free access and feature limits can change.

How often should I audit my website?

Review important technical and performance signals regularly, and run a more complete audit when you redesign the site, change platforms, experience a major search-performance shift or make substantial changes to the content and structure.

Does duplicate content cause a Google penalty?

Not automatically. Similar or duplicate URLs can create confusion about which page should be surfaced, waste crawl attention or create a poor user experience, but duplicate content by itself is not automatically a spam-policy violation.

Is Domain Authority a Google ranking factor?

No. Domain Authority is a third-party metric created by Moz. It can be used as one comparative research signal, but it is not a Google metric and should not be treated as a direct ranking factor.

Does my website need AMP to rank?

No. AMP is not a requirement for Google Search. Prioritise mobile usability, accessible content, reliable performance and a good overall page experience.

Can an SEO audit guarantee first-page rankings?

No. An audit can identify problems and opportunities, but rankings depend on many factors, including competition, relevance, quality, crawling, indexing and changes in search systems. No responsible consultant can guarantee a specific ranking date.

What should I do after receiving an SEO audit?

Prioritise the most important verified findings, agree on owners and implementation dates, fix the issues, validate the work and monitor the relevant search and business outcomes. Do not simply file the report away.

Need a Clearer Picture of Your Website's SEO?

If you own a business, blog, startup or growing brand and you are unsure what is holding your website back, I can help you review the evidence and identify practical next steps.

I work as an independent SEO consultant through IBIFOUNDRY LIMITED. My approach is to understand the website, its market and its business goals before recommending what should change.

Start a conversation about an SEO audit and website improvement plan.

This contact link opens WhatsApp with a topic-specific message. No audit, price or delivery time is promised by this article.

Build Your SEO Strategy on Evidence, Not Guesswork

The most useful SEO audit is not the one with the longest spreadsheet. It is the one that helps you understand what is happening, what matters most and what to do next.

That is why I use the OOK framework: understand your own website, study the competitive environment, and turn the evidence into a focused keyword and page strategy. Keep each page accountable for a distinct search intent, and improve existing assets before creating another page that says almost the same thing.

Which part of your website do you suspect needs the most attention right now: technical health, content, keywords or the pages competing with one another?

About the author

Simon Taki Zakuis the Founder and CEO of IBIFOUNDRY LIMITED. He works as an independent SEO consultant, helping businesses understand and improve their websites, content and organic search strategy.

Follow@realdrsimonfor updates and insights.

Sources and Further Reading


Comments


bottom of page